Porch Geese writes “Columbus (OH) Metropolitan Library recently moved to make their self-serve check-out system the only method patrons could use when borrowing materials from their main branch. They haven’t fired the circ staff, yet. And they haven’t exported that approach to any of the branches, yet, either. But there is a growing number of patrons who are unhappy about the removal of the human touch from their library experience.”
- Next A Quick Guide To the Grammy Awards For Librarians
- Previous NPR : Harlequin Books Seek a Younger Audience
Recent Posts
- Salem librarians report patrons trashing, hiding LGBTQ books in past year September 20, 2024
- Forbes Marketplace: The Parasite SEO Company Trying to Devour Its Host September 19, 2024
- Requests to remove books from public libraries are on the rise in Oregon. September 19, 2024
- Librarians on the Case! Sofie Kelly with a list of mysteries featuring bookish sleuths September 19, 2024
- Under Tennessee’s stricter school library law, some books quietly disappear September 19, 2024
- Prison censorship: Law libraries need Microsoft Word. September 19, 2024
- Why British Library’s open book about cyber hack is so important September 18, 2024
Recent Comments
- Dottie spears on The Black Section at WalMart; Segregating Titles by Subjects’ Skin Color
- Dee on The Black Section at WalMart; Segregating Titles by Subjects’ Skin Color
- Examining Arab and Muslim librarians in fiction – Pop Culture Library Review on Librarian Combats Muslim Stereotypes
- St. Paul libraries face moment of reckoning – LISNews – News For Librarians on Secret and mysterious libraries
- Ellie on Just How Gross Are Library Books, Exactly?
- Prodigious1one on The Teaching Librarian Versus The Teacher
LISNews Archives
- September 2024 (17)
- August 2024 (6)
- March 2024 (1)
- December 2023 (1)
- November 2023 (5)
- October 2023 (1)
- September 2023 (1)
- August 2023 (22)
- February 2023 (3)
- January 2023 (20)
- December 2022 (6)
- February 2022 (3)
- December 2021 (1)
- December 2020 (1)
- July 2020 (11)
- June 2020 (11)
- January 2020 (1)
- December 2019 (2)
- November 2019 (4)
- October 2019 (1)
- June 2019 (1)
- May 2019 (4)
- April 2019 (3)
- March 2019 (11)
- February 2019 (41)
- January 2019 (31)
- December 2018 (6)
- November 2018 (11)
- October 2018 (15)
- September 2018 (9)
- August 2018 (22)
- July 2018 (1)
- June 2018 (1)
- May 2018 (7)
- April 2018 (8)
- March 2018 (5)
- February 2018 (17)
- January 2018 (13)
- December 2017 (8)
- November 2017 (16)
- October 2017 (18)
- September 2017 (11)
- August 2017 (8)
- July 2017 (8)
- June 2017 (21)
- May 2017 (39)
- April 2017 (22)
- March 2017 (15)
- February 2017 (21)
- January 2017 (40)
- December 2016 (20)
- November 2016 (9)
- October 2016 (20)
- September 2016 (48)
- August 2016 (48)
- July 2016 (55)
- June 2016 (61)
- May 2016 (39)
- April 2016 (67)
- March 2016 (81)
- February 2016 (85)
- January 2016 (69)
- December 2015 (90)
- November 2015 (126)
- October 2015 (107)
- September 2015 (85)
- August 2015 (42)
- July 2015 (32)
- June 2015 (35)
- May 2015 (39)
- April 2015 (14)
- March 2015 (60)
- February 2015 (75)
- January 2015 (44)
- December 2014 (30)
- November 2014 (39)
- October 2014 (43)
- September 2014 (30)
- August 2014 (36)
- July 2014 (59)
- June 2014 (46)
- May 2014 (62)
- April 2014 (58)
- March 2014 (52)
- February 2014 (37)
- January 2014 (42)
- December 2013 (41)
- November 2013 (25)
- October 2013 (43)
- September 2013 (28)
- August 2013 (32)
- July 2013 (61)
- June 2013 (51)
- May 2013 (50)
- April 2013 (52)
- March 2013 (68)
- February 2013 (62)
- January 2013 (62)
- December 2012 (53)
- November 2012 (64)
- October 2012 (111)
- September 2012 (109)
- August 2012 (128)
- July 2012 (57)
- June 2012 (75)
- May 2012 (163)
- April 2012 (158)
- March 2012 (109)
- February 2012 (125)
- January 2012 (136)
- December 2011 (109)
- November 2011 (74)
- October 2011 (82)
- September 2011 (95)
- August 2011 (106)
- July 2011 (93)
- June 2011 (102)
- May 2011 (94)
- April 2011 (105)
- March 2011 (100)
- February 2011 (92)
- January 2011 (110)
- December 2010 (124)
- November 2010 (83)
- October 2010 (118)
- September 2010 (115)
- August 2010 (110)
- July 2010 (108)
- June 2010 (113)
- May 2010 (78)
- April 2010 (121)
- March 2010 (191)
- February 2010 (182)
- January 2010 (168)
- December 2009 (129)
- November 2009 (116)
- October 2009 (131)
- September 2009 (149)
- August 2009 (162)
- July 2009 (166)
- June 2009 (189)
- May 2009 (112)
- April 2009 (164)
- March 2009 (185)
- February 2009 (151)
- January 2009 (173)
- December 2008 (200)
- November 2008 (155)
- October 2008 (252)
- September 2008 (267)
- August 2008 (193)
- July 2008 (208)
- June 2008 (161)
- May 2008 (208)
- April 2008 (253)
- March 2008 (201)
- February 2008 (246)
- January 2008 (185)
- December 2007 (200)
- November 2007 (208)
- October 2007 (241)
- September 2007 (227)
- August 2007 (269)
- July 2007 (201)
- June 2007 (205)
- May 2007 (157)
- April 2007 (217)
- March 2007 (250)
- February 2007 (183)
- January 2007 (181)
- December 2006 (163)
- November 2006 (180)
- October 2006 (170)
- September 2006 (215)
- August 2006 (210)
- July 2006 (202)
- June 2006 (257)
- May 2006 (280)
- April 2006 (271)
- March 2006 (347)
- February 2006 (284)
- January 2006 (300)
- December 2005 (267)
- November 2005 (238)
- October 2005 (364)
- September 2005 (349)
- August 2005 (377)
- July 2005 (382)
- June 2005 (403)
- May 2005 (371)
- April 2005 (420)
- March 2005 (367)
- February 2005 (368)
- January 2005 (346)
- December 2004 (311)
- November 2004 (260)
- October 2004 (308)
- September 2004 (228)
- August 2004 (319)
- July 2004 (395)
- June 2004 (338)
- May 2004 (288)
- April 2004 (364)
- March 2004 (348)
- February 2004 (438)
- January 2004 (266)
- December 2003 (222)
- November 2003 (226)
- October 2003 (281)
- September 2003 (317)
- August 2003 (315)
- July 2003 (278)
- June 2003 (282)
- May 2003 (265)
- April 2003 (271)
- March 2003 (249)
- February 2003 (283)
- January 2003 (210)
- December 2002 (186)
- November 2002 (184)
- October 2002 (222)
- September 2002 (210)
- August 2002 (207)
- July 2002 (184)
- June 2002 (166)
- May 2002 (160)
- April 2002 (195)
- March 2002 (183)
- February 2002 (195)
- January 2002 (203)
- December 2001 (203)
- November 2001 (238)
- October 2001 (183)
- September 2001 (153)
- August 2001 (204)
- July 2001 (243)
- June 2001 (176)
- May 2001 (92)
- April 2001 (116)
- March 2001 (153)
- February 2001 (142)
- January 2001 (131)
- December 2000 (110)
- November 2000 (124)
- October 2000 (128)
- September 2000 (132)
- August 2000 (138)
- July 2000 (166)
- June 2000 (135)
- May 2000 (120)
- April 2000 (121)
- March 2000 (181)
- February 2000 (163)
- January 2000 (54)
- November 1999 (37)
Seems a little sad
While I’m sure Columbus has good reasons, it’s a shame that it has to be one or the other.
The new self-check machines at our public library are slick (much better than the previous generation), and I suspect they account for the bulk of circulation–but for people nervous about them, there’s a welcoming circ desk right across the way. Which rarely has lines, thanks to self-check.
Interesting
The Kmart near me had 4 self-checkout stations and apparently they were more trouble then they were worth because they were gone in less than a year.
I don’t believe a lot of libraries would make it an either-or situation, but if this became norm I would wonder if by disconnecting the human element libraries don’t hasten their own demise. Why go to a library to use a catalog to find a book to use a computer to check out a book when I can download the book at home and save myself the trip?
Re: disconnecting the human element libraries
That is interesting. In disconnecting the human element libraries are they making librarians less important? Libraries less important?
Good questions.
Being a tech…
I probably feel different about this than many people do, but I prefer self checks in many environments. Meijers (a large middlewestern chain that combines grocery shopping with light hardware, home, kitchen, clothing etc) has self checkout lanes and I really prefer them, of course that might be because their staffing of normal checkout lines is woefully inadequate.
I wish Borders had self checkout, especially during the Holidays, since I actualyl skipped buying books because the line was not worth it unless I had a need for a particular book.
I do not see it being a bad thing for libraries UNLESS it forces them to reduce staff, as long as they maintain current staffing and refocus those labor hours to other activities, this would be a win win.
grocery self-check out vs. library self-check out
The problem with grocery/retail self-check outs is trying to do too many things. If all you had to do was scan a card and scan grocery bar codes you’d be fine, but when you try to add vegies with no produce numbers, weight, coupons, five ways of payment it bogs down.
At our library in a Midwest micropolis, a few of our patrons would be grateful that they didn’t have their reading choices perused by the check-out staff. I remember an acquaintance half-pleading that I not tell anyone she was pregnant as she checked out “What to Expect When You’re Expecting” Of course I would never say a word, but she would have loved the self-check out.
On the flip side our older readers would picket if they were forced to use yet another computer.
I do reference in addition to circulation and I find check out is often reference-readers advisory in disguise. A machine will not ask the patron “did you find everything you needed?”
All this is obvious, but to me it underlines why I think Columbus is making a mistake.
Re:Being a tech…
I agree with you on most points. I prefer using the self-check cash registers at the grocery stores. But, I used to be a cashier and am pretty picky about how they pack my food and it’s faster for me most days.
However, I think generally libraries turn to self-check stations as a way to reduce staff or to deal with staff cuts. We have 1 self-check station installed here and it isn’t used as often as the desk. You can’t pick up holds at a self-check station, and we have certain age restrictions on certain items (ex:r-rated videos) that for the time-being staff members have to check ids. These problems are supposed to be worked out before we install stations at the rest of the branches, but we keep finding more and more problems so who knows how it will all end up.
What I wonder is, how does Columbus handle fines? Can the patron pay at the self-check station or does the reference desk have to take fines? Anybody out there know?
Re:Being a tech…
Columbus has had self checkout for the better part of a decade now. I loved it when I first discovered it. It was particularly useful in the video section upstairs, where the lines could get quite long on a Friday afternoon.
But what I’ve now discovered I loved best about it was the choice I had between using the self-serve system or interacting with a person who might help me with some question or extra issue.
Re:Seems a little sad
But it’s not a one or the other choice. Columbus has had self check available for many years now, and it’s been a great system. I don’t think they should get rid of it. And I don’t think they should get rid of staffed checkout either. It wasn’t one or the other. It was one or both, and Columbus chose one.
The staff is still there, but their workload has changed. If you need some assistance, you have to go get a staff member to come help you with the self checkout machine. Many patrons already have difficulty approaching staff. I can’t imagine this will help.
Re:Being a tech…
I work at a library that has self-charge machines. At our main branch we are using them almost exclusively, although if you really are in favor of having a person check you out, it’s available. However, I can tell you right now that the reason for using them was NOT to reduce staff, but to shift staff workload. The volume of circulation, inter-library loan, and so on has increased the back room work tremendously. The circulation folks just flat out don’t have the time to be helpin g the customers as much. There’s too much demand and too much work to do. I feel badly for those customers who don’t like this approach, but we have to face facts: libraries are under severe budget crunches right now, and the increased workload does help. The choice is to decrease staff to help with budget problems, or to keep the staff you have but shift their work so that they are most efficiently used.
Re:Being a tech…
This makes a lot of sense, and I applaud the concept of shifting workload without reducing staff.
I would much rather have a well staffed reference desk than a well staffed checkout desk.
Re:Seems a little sad
Right. To me it seems a little sad that Columbus made a choice of one. Our library chose both, which is a more patron-friendly choice.
Re:Being a tech…
Where do you work? I make it a habit to avoid any library system that refers to me as a “customer”.