The 20 Most Extreme Cases Of ‘The Book Was Better Than The Movie’

Submitted by Blake on Thu, 11/19/2015 - 09:00
Topic

Because there are extreme cases where book-lover rage is justifiable. Which cases? I pulled the Metacritic critic ratings of the top 500 movies on IMDb tagged with the “based on novel” keyword.1 I then2 found the average user rating of the source novel for each film on Goodreads, a book rating and review site.3 In the end, there was complete data for 382 films and source novels.

Here’s what each film’s Metacritic rating looks like plotted against its source material’s Goodreads rating

From The 20 Most Extreme Cases Of ‘The Book Was Better Than The Movie’ | FiveThirtyEight