Anonymous Patron writes “News From Michigan where Fliers denouncing the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday were found inside the Ypsilanti District Library on Monday, but did not disrupt the celebration. Library officials destroyed the fliers and continued with the programs.”
Recent Posts
- Florida teacher fired over viral video of empty library shelves after DeSantis branded it a “fake narrative” February 20, 2023
- New policies address paper mills and unprofessional conduct – The Official PLOS Blog February 19, 2023
- Librarians Are Finding Thousands Of Books No Longer Protected By Copyright Law February 19, 2023
- POLICY BRIEF: Opposing Attempts to Criminalize Librarianship through State Obscenity Laws January 20, 2023
- New Year, New Weed January 20, 2023
- The Smithsonian Will Restore Hundreds of the World’s Oldest Sound Recordings January 18, 2023
- The Most Unique Libraries in the World January 15, 2023
Recent Comments
- Examining Arab and Muslim librarians in fiction – Pop Culture Library Review on Librarian Combats Muslim Stereotypes
- St. Paul libraries face moment of reckoning – LISNews – News For Librarians on Secret and mysterious libraries
- Ellie on Just How Gross Are Library Books, Exactly?
- Prodigious1one on The Teaching Librarian Versus The Teacher
- Jason on Ten Stories That Shaped 2019
- centaurea on Libraries using Internet Trust Tools
LISNews Archives
- February 2023 (3)
- January 2023 (20)
- December 2022 (6)
- February 2022 (3)
- December 2021 (1)
- December 2020 (1)
- July 2020 (11)
- June 2020 (11)
- January 2020 (1)
- December 2019 (2)
- November 2019 (4)
- October 2019 (1)
- June 2019 (1)
- May 2019 (4)
- April 2019 (3)
- March 2019 (11)
- February 2019 (41)
- January 2019 (31)
- December 2018 (6)
- November 2018 (11)
- October 2018 (15)
- September 2018 (9)
- August 2018 (22)
- July 2018 (1)
- June 2018 (1)
- May 2018 (7)
- April 2018 (8)
- March 2018 (5)
- February 2018 (17)
- January 2018 (13)
- December 2017 (8)
- November 2017 (16)
- October 2017 (18)
- September 2017 (11)
- August 2017 (8)
- July 2017 (8)
- June 2017 (21)
- May 2017 (39)
- April 2017 (22)
- March 2017 (15)
- February 2017 (21)
- January 2017 (40)
- December 2016 (20)
- November 2016 (9)
- October 2016 (20)
- September 2016 (48)
- August 2016 (48)
- July 2016 (55)
- June 2016 (61)
- May 2016 (39)
- April 2016 (67)
- March 2016 (81)
- February 2016 (85)
- January 2016 (69)
- December 2015 (90)
- November 2015 (126)
- October 2015 (107)
- September 2015 (85)
- August 2015 (42)
- July 2015 (32)
- June 2015 (35)
- May 2015 (39)
- April 2015 (14)
- March 2015 (60)
- February 2015 (75)
- January 2015 (44)
- December 2014 (30)
- November 2014 (39)
- October 2014 (43)
- September 2014 (30)
- August 2014 (36)
- July 2014 (59)
- June 2014 (46)
- May 2014 (62)
- April 2014 (58)
- March 2014 (52)
- February 2014 (37)
- January 2014 (42)
- December 2013 (41)
- November 2013 (25)
- October 2013 (43)
- September 2013 (28)
- August 2013 (32)
- July 2013 (61)
- June 2013 (51)
- May 2013 (50)
- April 2013 (52)
- March 2013 (68)
- February 2013 (62)
- January 2013 (62)
- December 2012 (53)
- November 2012 (64)
- October 2012 (111)
- September 2012 (109)
- August 2012 (128)
- July 2012 (57)
- June 2012 (75)
- May 2012 (163)
- April 2012 (158)
- March 2012 (109)
- February 2012 (125)
- January 2012 (136)
- December 2011 (109)
- November 2011 (74)
- October 2011 (82)
- September 2011 (95)
- August 2011 (106)
- July 2011 (93)
- June 2011 (102)
- May 2011 (94)
- April 2011 (105)
- March 2011 (100)
- February 2011 (92)
- January 2011 (110)
- December 2010 (124)
- November 2010 (83)
- October 2010 (118)
- September 2010 (115)
- August 2010 (110)
- July 2010 (108)
- June 2010 (113)
- May 2010 (78)
- April 2010 (121)
- March 2010 (191)
- February 2010 (182)
- January 2010 (168)
- December 2009 (129)
- November 2009 (116)
- October 2009 (131)
- September 2009 (149)
- August 2009 (162)
- July 2009 (166)
- June 2009 (189)
- May 2009 (112)
- April 2009 (164)
- March 2009 (185)
- February 2009 (151)
- January 2009 (173)
- December 2008 (200)
- November 2008 (155)
- October 2008 (252)
- September 2008 (267)
- August 2008 (193)
- July 2008 (208)
- June 2008 (161)
- May 2008 (208)
- April 2008 (253)
- March 2008 (201)
- February 2008 (246)
- January 2008 (185)
- December 2007 (200)
- November 2007 (208)
- October 2007 (241)
- September 2007 (227)
- August 2007 (269)
- July 2007 (201)
- June 2007 (205)
- May 2007 (157)
- April 2007 (217)
- March 2007 (250)
- February 2007 (183)
- January 2007 (181)
- December 2006 (163)
- November 2006 (180)
- October 2006 (170)
- September 2006 (215)
- August 2006 (210)
- July 2006 (202)
- June 2006 (257)
- May 2006 (280)
- April 2006 (271)
- March 2006 (347)
- February 2006 (284)
- January 2006 (300)
- December 2005 (267)
- November 2005 (238)
- October 2005 (364)
- September 2005 (349)
- August 2005 (377)
- July 2005 (382)
- June 2005 (403)
- May 2005 (371)
- April 2005 (420)
- March 2005 (367)
- February 2005 (368)
- January 2005 (346)
- December 2004 (311)
- November 2004 (260)
- October 2004 (308)
- September 2004 (228)
- August 2004 (319)
- July 2004 (395)
- June 2004 (338)
- May 2004 (288)
- April 2004 (364)
- March 2004 (348)
- February 2004 (438)
- January 2004 (266)
- December 2003 (222)
- November 2003 (226)
- October 2003 (281)
- September 2003 (317)
- August 2003 (315)
- July 2003 (278)
- June 2003 (282)
- May 2003 (265)
- April 2003 (271)
- March 2003 (249)
- February 2003 (283)
- January 2003 (210)
- December 2002 (186)
- November 2002 (184)
- October 2002 (222)
- September 2002 (210)
- August 2002 (207)
- July 2002 (184)
- June 2002 (166)
- May 2002 (160)
- April 2002 (195)
- March 2002 (183)
- February 2002 (195)
- January 2002 (203)
- December 2001 (203)
- November 2001 (238)
- October 2001 (183)
- September 2001 (153)
- August 2001 (204)
- July 2001 (243)
- June 2001 (176)
- May 2001 (92)
- April 2001 (116)
- March 2001 (153)
- February 2001 (142)
- January 2001 (131)
- December 2000 (110)
- November 2000 (124)
- October 2000 (128)
- September 2000 (132)
- August 2000 (138)
- July 2000 (166)
- June 2000 (135)
- May 2000 (120)
- April 2000 (121)
- March 2000 (181)
- February 2000 (163)
- January 2000 (54)
- November 1999 (37)
Why did they destroy them?
I happen to think that MLK Jr was a philandering, plagerizing fraud.
I also happen to think he did wonderful things for civil rights in this country.
Do they have to be mutually exclusive? Can’t I dislike the man and like what he did. Are we not allowed to speak ill of the dead? I also think JFK was a drug addicted adulterer, but he kept nukes out of Cuba (Cuber).
Lots of people probably don’t like me, but the guy who was hit by lightning that I did CPR on is alive today. He probably thinks that was a good thing. Can’t you be a putz and do good things as well?
Why do librarians stifle differing, and unpopular opinions? That seems professionally irresponsible to me. To have ‘staff’ destroy things without a proper review -just as one would handle a book challenge- is simply wrong no matter how distasteful ‘staff’ may find them.
Re:Why did they destroy them?
At most of the libraries I know about, flyers posted in the bathroom would be removed for the inappropriateness of their location.
Re:Why did they destroy them?
Why isn’t the bathroom an appropriate place? I’ve been to many a bog where there are things posted. Some places even put the sports page above the urinals (although that seems to contribute to the damp floors).
The article noted that they were not posted solely in the bathroom. Does that make everything posted in the loo bad? Can I put up a READ poster over the thrones?
It seems they removed them because they didn’t like the content.
Re:Why did they destroy them?
I’ve seen this in bars. I’ve not seen this in libraries, and I don’t go to nearly as many bars as I do libraries. Being the primary caregiver for children still in diapers, I’ve seen the inside of the mensroom of most of the libraries I’ve visited. Maybe I just don’t get to the same sort of libraries you do.
I’d like to know, does your PL allow members of the public to post flyers anywhere they want to? Regardless of whether the prospective materials have to pass some arbitrary content filtration, I’ll bet there are policies regarding where the they can go, how large they can be (11×17 seems to be a common limit), how long they can stay up, tidy appearance of the area, etc.. Public libraries that don’t have policies like that run the risk of becoming dumping grounds and looking more like public toilets.
Try it some time (at a different PL, so that you are a member of the public, not an employee). Make up some flyers for something quite likely to pass any content filtration, say a local Red Cross blood drive, and put them up all around the library; in study carrols, in the meeting room, in the loo. I’m willing to wager that they’ll get removed because, regardless of content, they are in an inappropriate location. You’ll probably even generate some heat for a local Red Cross volunteer the next time they want to put up a flyer through legitimate channels.
Re:Why did they destroy them?
We allow flyers that are for community or non-commercial ventures. We allow them to be up for a week before the final date on the flyer.
We have the seperation of church and state groups and we have church picnics on the same board. We have had pro-abortion fliers, and GBLT fliers. I don’t like all of those causes, but it really does not matter.
Someone put up a self-made “RIB ODB” sticker in the john soon after Old Dirty Bastard died. Its still there.
So yes we have rules about what can be posted on our bulletin board but we don’t regulate personal speech (commercial speech as we all know is subject to more restriction). So do I think people should put up fliers that disparage MLK, no not really. Would I take them down, not until after MLK day. Would I late people put up fliers calling the Pope an Anti-Semite (an opinion I don’t share) yes, would I take them down? Yes after a week.
The library staff doesn’t have to like it, but they can’t remove it because they don’t like it. The article said the fliers were not just in the bathroom. It also says they destroyed the fliers because they were inappropriate. Who decides if they are inappropriate? No mention was made of any formal review. That is what should outrage librarians.
Do I think MLK was a great man, yes. Do I think this country is better off because he lived, sure I do. The Civil Rights advances made during the MLK, Rosa Parks era brought a modicum of equality to all in this nation. There is still a long way to go, but stifiling opinion will not move things along.
Re:Why did they destroy them?
I’m late to this discussion, but the issue that isn’t discussed in the article is whether or not flyers in that library must be approved before posting. In my experience at a few public and academic libraries, all flyers, regardless of content, must be submitted to a marketing office of some sort (or the library director if it’s a really small place) before being posted. If that was the case for this library, then they are justified in removing the unapproved flyers and doing with them what they wish.
That’s what we did at the public library I worked at–if somebody just posted something without following the library’s established procedure, the flyers got trashed. Does that make sense?
Now, if I found something controversial or offensive posted without approval, I would save it to show my coworkers–especially if it was really crazy, because that’s just good entertainment. 🙂