Anonymous Patron sent in an article from Reason Magazine that gives a concise and balanced overview of libraries’ reactions to CIPA, including quotes from Jessamyn West and library administrators in San Jose and Illinois. An excerpt:
The San Jose Public Libraries receive about $20,000 each year from the E-rate program, a federal effort to finance public access to the Internet. Next year, though, they might not get any. San Jose is one of several library systems around the country that say they will refuse Washington’s subsidies rather than accept the strings attached to them — specifically, the requirements of the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA), which Congress passed in 1999 and the Supreme Court upheld in June
Cost/Benefit
While San Jose should be applauded for taking a stand against CIPA, foregoing $20,000.00 may be unecessary.
Some filters can be configured to minimally comply with CIPA and to allow adult patrons to “click through” to blocked content. This preserves frist ammendment rights as well as E-rate.
The real answer for CIPA is to mount a political campaign to have the law repealed or ammended. It is not to turn down funds which virtually every library needs.