Shelfari - Maybe Evil?

Well, this article did come from LibraryThing's blog, so I'm sure there might be some bias, but they are talking about the dubious email-a-friend practices of one of their competitors, Shelfari. Being against accidentally emailing everyone in my entire address book, I think I'll give them a miss. It is, however, also interesting to see LibraryThing's "take" on who their competitors are.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

what Shelfari says

I've been an active member of Shelfari for about 3 months, and only just heard about their "evil spamminess" earlier this week. Of course, I never used their invite-a-friend app, so I wouldn't have been involved in it. For the purpose of balancing the bias of LibraryThing's post with an opposite bias, here's what Shelfari folks are saying on their blog (with a few comments). For what it's worth, I'm not a huge fan of LibraryThing (joined it a couple of years ago, have never used it beyond a few exploratory logins) -- it just doesn't really suit my purposes. Shelfari has some nice features and a lot of shortcomings (hey! it's in beta) ... I like GoodReads better.
... {Mock Turtle} ...

Clearing the air

Hi Anders,

It is true that there was a pretty big problem with our invitation system, which we fixed last week. I just posted a fairly detailed description of what happened and how it's solved. Take a minute to decide for yourself.

http://shelfari.typepad.com/my_weblog/2007/11/invitation-desi.html

Thanks,

Josh

Syndicate content